This was excerpted, by Tom Barton from an article originally published in USA Today, August 5, 2008
Hearing loss is one of the most common ailments that affects troops sent back to combat, according to the Pentagon and government researchers.
One in four soldiers serving in Iraq or Afghanistan have damaged hearing, the Army said.
Dunne, who in Iraq was part of the 4th Infantry Division at Fort Hood, is now back home. Besides his hearing problems, he shows signs of PTSD and has severe back problems.
After more than five years of war marked by multiple deployments, many combat veterans are developing long-term health problems, raising the risk that ailing troops are being sent back into combat.
Since 2003, 43,000 troops who were classified as medically unfit in the weeks prior to deployment were still sent to war, Pentagon statistics show.
"As much as I wanted to get out there …, I’m seriously physically challenged by not being able to hear," Dunne wrote. "The guys to my left and right don’t deserve anything to happen to them because of my personal pride."
"I’m now at 29, feeling like I’m 50," he wrote before leaving Baghdad.
He has fought off and on in Iraq since 2003, when his unit was profiled by USA Today. Dunne has been in occasional contact with the newspaper since then.
Meanwhile, Dunne began a series of routine medical exams and screenings to understand the war’s toll on him.
Doctors found:
- Hearing loss. His hearing declined dramatically during Dunne’s first tour. Army audiological records show loss in various frequencies, particularly in his left ear, said Anthony Cacace, an audiologist and professor at Wayne State University in Detroit. Cacace reviewed Dunne’s medical test records provided by USA Today.
The weakness leaves him struggling to hear consonant sounds, especially if there is background noise.
"He’s going to have one hell of a time understanding what people say if he can’t get visual cues," Cacace said, adding Dunne has the hearing of a 70-year-old in his right ear and worse than that in his left.
- Severe lower back pain dating to his first Iraq tour from April 2003 to April 2004. By his third tour, Dunne required regular painkiller injections.
- PTSD symptoms after his second tour, when Dunne was near a suicide bomb explosion.
- Tinnitus, or ringing in the ears that never stops.
To sleep, he listens to rock music on his iPod, a common means of coping for troops with tinnitus, said Army Maj. Dan Ohama, an audiologist working in Baghdad.
Service-connected back and neck injuries have left nearly 50,000 Iraq- and Afghanistan-era veterans permanently disabled, Department of Veterans Affairs records show. VA has treated 75,000 such veterans for PTSD and placed nearly 35,000 on permanent disability.
And almost 70,000 suffer from tinnitus, VA records show.
In December, weeks before Dunne went to Iraq for his third tour, his company commander spelled out the staff sergeant’s chief physical problems.
The soldier’s battle-damaged hearing, Capt. Alex Garn wrote, "limits his ability to identify enemy locations by sound, hear commands from his team leaders, hear radio traffic over a squad radio, or speak with local nationals in combat, which could have negative ramifications to the mission."
On Dec. 19, the chief physician and medical commander at Fort Hood, Texas, where Dunne is based, urged that he be taken out of infantry.
"At risk of continued hearing loss," Col. Jeffrey Clark wrote.
Clark was the only doctor on a five-member panel reviewing Dunne’s fitness for combat on Dec. 19. He was overruled by the other four panelists.
Dunne’s brigade commander and three senior sergeants agreed that Dunne should stay in infantry and go to Iraq.
"Hearing loss is present in all forms … in the Army," wrote one panelist, Master Sgt. Ulysses Martin.
"It’s impossible to validate whether he will lose his hearing more or less in the future. I feel that infantry is his best place."
One factor in their decision was Dunne’s desire to return despite his hearing loss. He said he felt a responsibility to be with his platoon. His unit’s young soldiers, he wrote from Iraq, "needed as much help as they can get."
"That’s pride," said Geni Gillaspie, Dunne’s girlfriend and the mother of his two children. "That’s Kevin … wanting to lead his men and do the right thing."
The attitude impressed Dunne’s brigade commander, Col. Theodore Martin.
"Very dedicated soldier," Martin wrote during the review. "Wants to stay infantry. This is his life. I vote he stays infantry."
Despite his desire to deploy, Dunne thought his commanders would limit his combat exposure because of his hearing loss.
Garn had recommended in his memorandum that Dunne be given a hearing aid to wear into combat.
Neither happened.
During that April firefight, Dunne realized he was truly handicapped.
"I came to terms with myself and realized that I was not as confident in my ability to continue my job," he wrote in an e-mail May 6. "It was better for me to realize this than to ignore it."
Even then, he said, he hesitated to speak up.
"I don’t know how to approach (commanders) and tell them of what my feelings are," he wrote in an e-mail April 26, "because I’ve been around long enough to know that I’ll be looked at as a quitter."
Army regulations allow troops with health problems to go to war if their job comports with their physical limitations and if there are resources in the combat zone — such as psychological counseling — to treat them.
But a Government Accountability Office report released June 10 found the rules are not always followed.
It said that after doctors identified significant health issues among dozens of soldiers from three installations — Fort Drum in New York and Forts Stewart and Benning in Georgia — infantry commanders failed to limit their duties or schedule review boards to determine whether they should be moved to different jobs or out of the Army.
Troops with hearing unfit for combat are showing up in the war zone, Ohama said.
"We see cases of soldiers deploying when they did not meet the hearing standards," he said.
As troops prepare for war, medical officers need to be forceful, said S. Ward Casscells, the Pentagon’s chief of military medicine.
"The commander has to make the call based on the mission, but the doctors should make the case very clearly that deploying Cpl. X against his or her medical judgment is a decision that could be held against the commander," Casscells wrote in his Internet blog.
The risks of a mistake are too high, said James Martin, a retired colonel and expert on military culture at Bryn Mawr College in Pennsylvania.
"This is a disability you don’t want to get worse," he said. "You don’t want this person to be put in a position where he might hurt himself or others."
At the time of the April attack, the forward operating base in Baghdad where Dunne was deployed was under constant mortar and rocket fire.
He sought counseling with one of the Army’s combat stress teams.
"They say my symptoms are mimicking signs of depression. Who the hell knows what that means?" he wrote on May 6.
"They gave me three sheets of paper with breathing techniques, another describing how to imagine being in a happy place … and to remind myself to relax when I started getting anxious."
With the installation under daily rocket or mortar fire, Dunne said, the recommendations were impractical.
"For them to tell me to think happy is what will resolve my issues immediately — I have no faith in their judgment," he wrote May 22.
Dunne finally was moved from the front lines only after he complained by e-mail to Gillaspie; his mother, Diann Dunne; and after USA Today inquired about Dunne’s combat fitness.
He was given another hearing exam by Ohama in Baghdad. The results confirmed the earlier findings.
Martin said it is a mistake to rely too heavily on the service member suffering the disability when it comes to the question of fitness.
"You can’t ask the person to make the determination because emotionally, they’re too connected to wanting to overcome their disability."
In a telephone interview from Texas, Dunne said he is uncertain about his long-term future.
Another fitness hearing is scheduled and he has been assigned to a rear-detachment unit.
So shortly before coming home, Dunne accepted an offer to re-enlist for three years with an $11,000 bonus. He hoped the Army would find a place for him away from combat.
Last week, he said he received some good news on that front — a new assignment as a casualty liaison officer for 4th Infantry Division wounded who arrive at the Army’s Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany. All casualties from Iraq and Afghanistan pass through that facility.
"I get back to helping out and doing things for these guys," he said. "I’m really excited."
Comments